Match the sound to how you celebrate
Think about where the anniversary song will play. A quiet dinner at home suits an acoustic ballad with soft piano. A party with friends can take a brighter pop or country sound with a big final chorus. If you have a song you both love, describe its feel in the style box rather than naming the track, for example slow soul with warm horns. Every song comes back as two takes. Listen to both with headphones, then once out loud, and keep the one that sounds like the two of you.
